For the people who don’t understand. Everyone remembers their past, well at least the main characters. Oscar does remember his past. Ines was the first to remember then Oscar. That’s why he was trying so hard to get her in his hands in this life as well. It was pretty much out there around a chapter 80-90 ish.
The last thing I remember reading about this manga was that Carcel visited Emiliano at the church! But the!!!! I don’t understand! This means that Ines, carcel and Emiliano remember their previous lives but why Oscar is not theirs! Or, he remembers, that’s why he has this obsession with Ines!?
It wasn’t more like of a Sin @pinkcrayon smth about their wish together when they died in the “First Timeline” specifically not the timeline of Oscar and Ines Marriage it was her “Second Life” not “First”
Emiliano and Carcel: do you remember? You remember? I remember too
Emiliano: You’re actually kinda of lucky, cause I remember EVERYTHING as punishment for our sins. You’re getting them as ‘dreams’ and it’s probably God sending you said memories to help you out. You aren’t like Ines and I – who remember everything to the T. *this part was confusing in the novel*
Carcel: low key having an existential crisis cause he’s like “hold on… I remember this and this now. Oscar calling Ines his wife and then fiancé and then the next minute she’s looking really poor and rough with a baby but full of love and conviction and me being devastated about her loving other men when I really didn’t know her like that……
Carcel: ….,.. wait….. does Ines still love this man?
Upcoming arc between carcel and emaliiano is basically talking about Ines and Emiliano telling Carcel, I’m not going to see her. I don’t want to see her – especially after finding out what she did to our child . I will always love her but what we had wasn’t really love it was more of infuation and in a way superficial on both ends, but it wasn’t substantial love.
And idk if the WEBTOON is going into depth about it cause their religion is based of Catholicism and they don’t believe in reincarnation and what they experiencing isn’t really reincarnation, it’s something else.
NO INES BRO WHY IS THIS HAPPENING WHAT DID SHE EVEN DO THAT SHE SINNED SO BAD LIKE IF SHES REPEATING HER LIFE SHOULDNT LIKE HALF THE POPULATION BE BURNING IN HELL FOREVER???
Hopelessromantic779
WARNING SPOILER COMMENT BELOW
Roockiecookie
For the people who don’t understand. Everyone remembers their past, well at least the main characters. Oscar does remember his past. Ines was the first to remember then Oscar. That’s why he was trying so hard to get her in his hands in this life as well. It was pretty much out there around a chapter 80-90 ish.
Pietchan
My fellow confused folks…
Dazai66
Ion rlly get it reborn or not she’s still repeating her life
Love me
The last thing I remember reading about this manga was that Carcel visited Emiliano at the church! But the!!!! I don’t understand! This means that Ines, carcel and Emiliano remember their previous lives but why Oscar is not theirs! Or, he remembers, that’s why he has this obsession with Ines!?
Whalien27
I’m happy that I’m not the only one who is confused 🫠
milliecrepe
@Hopelessromantic thanks for the explanation :’)
Jinshi
It wasn’t more like of a Sin @pinkcrayon smth about their wish together when they died in the “First Timeline” specifically not the timeline of Oscar and Ines Marriage it was her “Second Life” not “First”
Hopelessromantic779
Basically to those who are confused:
Emiliano and Carcel: do you remember? You remember? I remember too
Emiliano: You’re actually kinda of lucky, cause I remember EVERYTHING as punishment for our sins. You’re getting them as ‘dreams’ and it’s probably God sending you said memories to help you out. You aren’t like Ines and I – who remember everything to the T. *this part was confusing in the novel*
Carcel: low key having an existential crisis cause he’s like “hold on… I remember this and this now. Oscar calling Ines his wife and then fiancé and then the next minute she’s looking really poor and rough with a baby but full of love and conviction and me being devastated about her loving other men when I really didn’t know her like that……
Carcel: ….,.. wait….. does Ines still love this man?
SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILER SPOILERS SPOILERS
Upcoming arc between carcel and emaliiano is basically talking about Ines and Emiliano telling Carcel, I’m not going to see her. I don’t want to see her – especially after finding out what she did to our child . I will always love her but what we had wasn’t really love it was more of infuation and in a way superficial on both ends, but it wasn’t substantial love.
And idk if the WEBTOON is going into depth about it cause their religion is based of Catholicism and they don’t believe in reincarnation and what they experiencing isn’t really reincarnation, it’s something else.
Della21
Is anyone else kinda confused??
Ramiamitu
Can’t wait to see Ines.
Itsssmeeeagain
Someone pls explain what’s happening my pea brain ain’t processing this all at once
pinkcrayon
NO INES BRO WHY IS THIS HAPPENING WHAT DID SHE EVEN DO THAT SHE SINNED SO BAD LIKE IF SHES REPEATING HER LIFE SHOULDNT LIKE HALF THE POPULATION BE BURNING IN HELL FOREVER???
Lobalovy
Thank u more